The Effects of War: Martial Law in Hawaii
In the immediate aftermath of the surprise attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, while the rest of the United States was gearing up for the great fight against the Axis Powers, the Hawaiian Islands were still stunned by what had happened in their midst.
Though not yet a state, responsibility for Hawaii’s safety went to US officials due to its status as an American territory, and their actions after the attack were influenced by paranoia, fear, and a perceived lack of options.
This is the history of martial law in Hawaii.
While there was no question of who the enemy was, that actually made the situation in the islands even more difficult. At the time, approximately 37% of the population were people of Japanese descent, and although some—out of fear of insider attacks—thought it would be prudent to imprison them all and let the islands try to function as normally as possible, that course of action would have been impossible for many reasons.
Seeing no other course of action, US officials placed Hawaii under martial law, and everyone, regardless of ethnicity, was forced to live under conditions that have since been called unfair and even extreme.
Martial Law in Hawaii
Even while the USS Arizona, Pearl Harbor, and the surrounding airfields were still in flames, the Hawaiian Islands were placed under martial law. Believing that anyone could be an enemy, military officials took no chances, keeping an eye on all residents, though they paid extra-close attention to Japanese-Americans.
In anticipation of a second attack, residents were ordered to dig makeshift bomb shelters. Beaches were no longer just places for recreation and instead looked like military zones. Barbed wire was everywhere. Military officials tried to let residents go about their daily lives, but there was much that got in the way of that goal.
At sundown, a complete blackout took effect, and a strict dusk-to-dawn curfew was enforced. Civil liberties were curtailed, and civilian courts were suspended.
For three years after the attack on Pearl Harbor, conditions in the islands were difficult. Under martial law in Hawaii, food was rationed, liquor and bars were strictly controlled, and even photography along the coasts was banned.
This period in history was a miserable time for island residents, partially due to fear of a potential threat from Japan, but mainly due to the impossible conditions in which they suddenly found themselves living.
The End of Martial Law in Hawaii
Martial law in Hawaii lasted for nearly three years after the attack on Pearl Harbor, long after the threat of another invasion had passed. Martial law ended in stages between 1943 and 1944. Once the initial fear subsided, both territorial officials and civilian leaders began protesting the curfews, loss of civilian courts, and the strict military regime. Legal challenges were also filed against the military for detaining citizens without charges.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt agreed to a compromise despite objections from the military. In February 1943, power was restored to the territory governor, state legislature, and civilian courts. However, the military stayed in control of labor and wages, and the military-appointed governor remained in place.
In July of 1944, the Office of the Military Governor was renamed the Office of Internal Security. Later that year, martial law was fully terminated. Presidential Proclamation No. 2627 on October 24, 1944 restored the writ of habeas corpus to the territory of Hawaii.

"Cleaning up the apron at Ford Island" - This photograph was taken by an unnamed Naval photographer immediately after the attack. The photo was used in a writ of application for Habeas Corpus case number 298 tried in the U.S. District Court for the District of Hawaii in 1944. The case, "In Re Lloyd C. Duncan," related to the imposition of martial law in Hawaii during World War II.
Duncan vs. Kahanamoku
In 1946, the legality of martial law in Hawaii was retrospectively challenged by the landmark Supreme Court case Duncan vs Kahanamoku.
Lloyd C. Duncan, a civilian shipfitter, was tried and convicted by a military court for a brawl in the shipyard involving two armed Marines. The acting military sheriff at the time was Duke Kahanamoku, and as a result, he was named as the nominal defendant in the case. The case reached the U.S. Supreme Court after Martial Law in Hawaii had already been terminated.
SCOTUS ruled in favor of Duncan and held that the tribunal was not authorized by the Hawaiian Organic Act and that the military did not have the authority to replace open and functioning civilian courts.
In his opinion, Chief Justice Harlan Fiske Stone focused on the lack of necessity for military intervention when the civilian courts were fully functional, and the threat of another invasion had long passed. Stone concluded that the military failed to justify keeping civilian courts closed, and this was a misuse of their authority.
Duncan vs Kahanamoku set a legal precedent that military tribunals cannot replace functional civilian courts when trying civilians under martial law. The military does not have the authority to usurp civilian courts or try civilians for ordinary crimes when civilian courts are open and functional under any circumstances.
Further, this challenge to martial law in Hawaii set a legal precedent that military authority is subordinate to civilian rule in any non-occupied U.S. territory. This case set a crucial legal limit to executive or military overreach during national emergencies.
To learn more about martial law in Hawaii:
- In person: The Road to War and Attack Museum at the Pearl Harbor National Memorial has a Martial Law Exhibit which details how the military assumed control of Hawaii, suspended habeas corpus, fingerprinted civilians, and enforced curfews. The Battleship Missouri Museum also features exhibits on life after the attack and under military rule.
In downtown Honolulu, there is a permanent exhibition entitled "Martial Law in Hawaii: 1941-1944" at the King Kamehameha V Judiciary History Center. It explores life under martial law, the military tribunals, and covers the many legal challenges to martial law, like Duncan vs. Kahanamoku.
Online: You can watch a National Park Service interpretive ranger take you through the Road to War and Attack Museum's Martial Law exhibit here.










